- Abdullah, M., Hassan, A., Madni, A. R., & Nawaz, T. (2014). “Portrayal of fashion by Tuskiash & Pakistani dramas on major private TV channels (Hum TV & Urdu 1) and viewers perception,†Asian Journal of Empirical Research, February, 2014,
- Anwar, Z. (2014). Pakistani dramas that dare to be different, DAWN,
- Babran, S. (2008). Media, Globalization of Culture, and Identity Crisis in developing Countries, Iran: Islamic Azad University.
- Concalvo, M. (2006) ‘Concole video games and global corporations: crating a hybrid culture’, London, Thousand Oaks, CA and New Delhi 8(1), 117-137.
- Giddens, A. (1999a). Globalization: An irresistible force. Daily Yumiuri, 7.
- Hannan, I., Kham, N., Mumtaz, A., Saleem, A. B., Tariq, S., & Yousaf, U. (2011). “Impact of Turkiash Dramas on Pakistani: A case study of International Islamic University Islamabadâ€. Unpublished Thesis
- Khalid, A. (2010). “Impact of star plus soap operas on lifestyle of students of University of Sargodha†Master’s Thesis, Department of communication studies, University of Sargodha.
- The extension of man. New York: McGrew Hill
- McLuhan, M., & Fiore, Q. (1968). “War and Peace in the global villageâ€. New York: Bantam.
- Morley, D. (1971). “Globalization and Cultural Imperialism Reconsidered: Old Questions in New Guises" From Curran, J. and Morley, D. (Eds) Media and Cultural Theory. New York, Rout-ledge, 2006. 3043.
- Muzaffar, C. (2002). Globalization and religion: Some reflections,
- Sonwalker, P. (2001). India: Makings of little cultural/media Imperialism? Gazette, 63(6), 505-51.
- Sparks, C. (2000). The Global, the Local and the Public Sphere. In Georgette Wang, Jan Servaes and Anura Goonasekera (Eds.). The New Communications Landscape: Demystifying Media Globalization, 74- 95. London: Routledge.
- Tomlinson, J. (1997). Cultural Globalization and Cultural Imperialism. In A. Mohammadi (Ed.), International Communication and Globalization. London, Thousand Oaks & and New Delhi: Sage Publication.
- Ullah, I. (2003). The Impact of the cable networks on the youth, Gomal University mass communication. Dera Ismail Khan (master’s thesis: unpublished), P.1.
- Wang, D. (2008). Globalization of Media: Does it Undermines National Culture?. China: Communication University.
Abstract:
This study is about the effects of Urdu-dubbed Turkish dramas on Pakistani society: A case of the Foundation University of Rawalpindi. With the help of a questionnaire, data is collected from the students. The reason for selecting such students is that the youth is more exposed to such dramas and easily get influenced by the new trends. One hundred students are selected on the basis of age, gender and education and apply the Stratification sampling method. The result indicated that the people of our society are getting influenced by Turkish dramas. And Turkish dramas are significantly having effects on our society as they are directly undermining our national culture.
Key Words
Urdu-dubbed Turkish Dramas, Effects, Pakistani Society, Youth, Influence, Impacts, Undermining of Culture
Introduction Globalization
Globalization is the contact and integration of people, corporations, and governments from other countries, helped by information technology and propelled by international commerce and investment. According to Sparks, no media is genuinely global (2000). Furthermore, the audience of the so-called global press is "too small, too wealthy, and too English-speaking to be considered inclusive," and it has ramifications for the environment, culture, political systems, economic development and prosperity, and human physical well-being in all societies around the world (Hannan et al., 2011). According to Sonwalker 2001), the foreign content isn't new to Pakistani media, but there have been instances when Indian channels were granted access to Pakistani television sets. However, it was later realized that having such simple and extensive access to Indian networks left Pakistani culture vulnerable to addiction to prominent Indian family channels, Star Plus and Sony. All of the Indian content was produced in Hindi, a language easily understood by Pakistanis. As a result, Pakistani society grew more open, absorbing and replicating features of Indian culture shown in dramas and television shows (Saleem, 2012)
Pakistan is a developing country with a large population exposed to media content. According to Saleem (2012). The majority of people believe it is the religion of Islam. Islam is more than a religion; it is a way of life or, to put it another way, a culture that dictates how a person should conduct themself in all parts of life. Today, dramas from Turkey, another Islamic country, are telecast on Pakistani television. It was assumed that their lifestyles would be similar because Pakistan and Turkey are both Islamic countries. However, modern plays portray Turkey as a country with an entirely different culture, which is not the fact.
Turkey is portrayed as radically contrary to Pakistani society and culture regarding women's clothes, food, alcohol consumption (drink illegally by Muslims), illegitimate love patterns, community, norms, and all other aspects. These dramas depict an Islamic society that is vastly different from Pakistan's (Mumtaz, 2012). The study's purpose is to recognize the damage that the dramas mentioned above provide to Pakistani culture, as well as to educate Pakistanis to recognize and adequately view such things, as well as to select what they should include in their lives and what they should avoid. The studies also assist media commentators and government officials in determining the cost-benefit analysis of disclosing the information. To such westernized content, the nation should devote more attention to content innovation, which must be developed locally, focusing on societal welfare.
Objectives
1. To investigate the viewership of Turkish dramas.
2. To find out the negative and positive influence of Turkish culture penetrated through dramas.
3. To check out the invasion of western culture into the national culture.
4. To examine the effects of the educated segment of males and females about Turkish culture and values.
5. To compute the threat effects about our family and social institution.
Research Question
Does the globalization of media just affect our basic cultural values and norms or influence and change the fashion or dressing style?
Hypothesis
1. It is more likely that the exposure to Turkish culture through Turkish dramas on Pakistani channels results in an effect on the socio-ethical perception of female viewers.
2. It is more likely that the Turkish drams are focusing on our society's concepts about marriage and divorce than on female education.
3. It is more likely that the Turkish Dramas are losing their modesty in the name of modernity.
Literature Review
Morley (1971), in 'Globalization and Cultural Imperialist Reassessed,' believes that present cultural imperialism patterns have progressed. New technology has displaced old trends that impacted civilizations in the past. Political, military, and economic domination, he believes, has a considerable cultural influence on lesser nations. He feels that Western cultural imperialism has an impact. One of the most well-known types of popular entertainment is dramas. The media's principal functions include providing information, education, entertainment, and cultural imperialism. These days, people are viewing more minor and less television. Television broadcast was prohibited for many years, but technology has advanced, and the golden age of Pakistani dramas has arrived (Khalid, 2010).
According to McLuhan's beliefs, this is tied to expanding new communication technology (1968, 1964). On the other hand, others claim that globalization has failed to create a unified political and economic identity (Rajaei, 2001). On the other hand, cultural globalization has resulted in the obliteration of national identities. "We are experiencing cultural globalization that is not the net result of human activities and experiences, and it has not equitably gained from cultural diversity," one of the world's leading theorists contends (Tomlinson, Skelton, and Allen, 1999, p. 23). Instead, it is a manifestation of the supremacy of a dominating culture. According to another author (Mia Consalvo, p118, 2006), cultural imperialism is a two-way street in which industrialized countries influence underdeveloped countries. She thinks that countries with more cultures and traditions have a higher ability to control even the most sophisticated and powerful nations.
Television shows include dramas, talk shows, comedy shows, sports shows, news, game shows, and chat shows, to name a few. Even though several channels are available, viewers do not watch all of them or even the majority; instead, they overlook two to five of the most popular ones. Each family receives an average of 36 channels, although only around half of them are seen (Beck, Huang, Pollard, & Johnson, 2003). It is widely accepted that children's and adolescents' mental and psychological patterns accurately predict their future. In this atmosphere, cable channel functions have become more lively than ever before. Increased emotional ties to entertainment programmes change the recipients' values and behaviour (Ullah, 2003). Television is widely considered to embody and strengthen patriarchy, which is currently the dominant ideology in Western civilization. Female television demos have changed dramatically in the last 20 years to accommodate the rising status of women in society (Khalid, 2010). Inverted colonialism refers to the impact of non-western countries on the development of western culture and economics (Giddens, 1999a). The year 2014 (Answer), Pakistani dramas are lovely because they are grounded in reality and more representational, whereas Western entertainment is a waste of time (Muzaffar, 2002). Global consumerism produces a single global culture, with indigenous South American traditions being replaced by Western civilizations
Theoretical Framework
This research aims to learn more about how media globalization is eroding natural culture. The goal of the study is to understand more about the consequences and impacts of watching "Urdu-dubbed Turkish plays" on Pakistani culture and society and how such dramas influence audience ideas and perspectives on everyday life. This research is based on a single concept called Cultivation Theory. The theory is briefly discussed below in connection to the current investigation. In various situations, approaches are developed to explain, forecast, and grasp facts and to question and extend existing knowledge, all while maintaining within the confines of crucial restrictive assumptions. According to this hypothesis, television and the media have a minor but essential influence on society's attitudes and beliefs. Those who watch a lot of television are more likely to be affected. (Theory of Mass Communication, 2017).
Methodology
This research aimed to explore how media globalization is eroding natural culture. The
means and logical procedure for putting a research strategy or approach into action is methodology. The fundamental goal of this research is to see if cultivation theory is applicable. The survey method is seen as a promising approach for acquiring information and data analysis, given the nature of the investigation. Both men and women watch Urdu-dubbed Turkish programmes on Pakistani television stations. It comprises university students studying natural and social disciplines who have seen Turkish dramas. Male and female University students serve as the study's unit of analysis. To meet the study's needs, the procedure established population subgroups, used a stratified technique to define demographic data, and separated the population by age, gender, discipline, and education. A stratified target of one hundred respondents has been set for data gathering. The purposive sampling methodology will be used to collect data after the strata of the stratified technique have been identified.
Analysis
The findings are based on a poll of 100 students who were asked nine closed-ended questions about Turkish dramas. The purpose of this poll is to see how Turkish dramas influence our culture.
Table 1. Storyline of Turkish dramas?
| width="86"> Frequency width="76">Percent width="84">Valid Percent width="128">Cumulative Percent | > Valid width="136" valign="top">Entertaining width="86">51 width="76">51.0 width="84">51.0 width="128">51.0 | > Thought provoking width="86">18 width="76">18.0 width="84">18.0 width="128">69.0 | > Boring width="86">31 width="76">31.0 width="84">31.0 width="128">100.0 | > Total width="86">100 width="76">100.0 width="84">100.0 width="128">
| |
Furthermore, it concludes that 51% of people think that the storyline of Turkish dramas is entertaining rather than boring or thought provoking
Table 2. The Society is Adopting Cultural Norms of Turkish Dramas?
| width="96"> Frequency width="85">Percent width="115">Valid Percent width="122">Cumulative Percent | > Valid width="61" valign="top">yes width="96">74 width="85">74.0 width="115">74.0 width="122">74.0 | > no width="96">26 width="85">26.0 width="115">26.0 width="122">100.0 | > Total width="96">100 width="85">100.0 width="115">100.0 width="122">
| |
It concludes that 74% of the individuals think that our society is adopting cultural norms of Turkish dramas, while 26% of people think that our society is not adopting cultural norms of Turkish dramas.
Table 3. Broadcasting Turkish Drams in Pakistan Morally/ethically Right
| width="78"> Frequency width="84">Percent width="96">Valid Percent width="118">Cumulative Percent | > Valid width="107" valign="top">yes width="78">25 width="84">25.0 width="96">25.0 width="118">25.0 | > no width="78">23 width="84">23.0 width="96">23.0 width="118">48.0 | > To some extent width="78">52 width="84">52.0 width="96">52.0 width="118">100.0 | > Total width="78">100 width="84">100.0 width="96">100.0 width="118">
| |
Moreover, 25% of people think that Broadcasting Turkish drama in Pakistan morally/ethically right while 23% think that it is not right and 52% of people think that to some extent it is morally/ethically right to broadcast Turkish dramas.
Table 4. Is Influenced by the Turkish Fashion
| width="90"> Frequency width="79">Percent width="108">Valid Percent width="113">Cumulative Percent | > Valid width="91" valign="top">very much width="90">15 width="79">15.0 width="108">15.0 width="113">15.0 | > much width="90">39 width="79">39.0 width="108">39.0 width="113">54.0 | > somewhat width="90">29 width="79">29.0 width="108">29.0 width="113">83.0 | > rarely width="90">12 width="79">12.0 width="108">12.0 width="113">95.0 | > never width="90">5 width="79">5.0 width="108">5.0 width="113">100.0 | > Total width="90">100 width="79">100.0 width="108">100.0 width="113">
| |
15% believe that our society is very much being influenced by the Turkish fashion, 39% think that it is much influenced, while 29% think it is somewhat, for 12% it is rarely and only 5% believe that our society is never being influenced by the Turkish fashion.
Table 5. Turkish Dramas Play a Vital Role in Increase in the Rating of the Pakistani Channels
| width="87"> Frequency width="81">Percent width="106">Valid Percent width="135">Cumulative Percent | > Valid width="87" valign="top">very much width="87">20 width="81">20.0 width="106">20.0 width="135">20.0 | > much width="87">53 width="81">53.0 width="106">53.0 width="135">73.0 | > somewhat width="87">18 width="81">18.0 width="106">18.0 width="135">91.0 | > rarely width="87">5 width="81">5.0 width="106">5.0 width="135">96.0 | > never width="87">4 width="81">4.0 width="106">4.0 width="135">100.0 | > Total width="87">100 width="81">100.0 width="106">100.0 width="135">
| |
Turkish dramas are playing a vital role in increase in rating of the Pakistani channels, as it is clearly shown by the results that 53% people agreed to this, while 20% claims to very much, 18% to somewhat, 5% believe it is rarely a fact and for 4% it is never playing a vital role.
Table 6. Pakistani Media Channels are buying Foreign Dramas in order to
| width="78"> Frequency width="84">Percent width="99">Valid Percent width="119">Cumulative Percent | > Valid width="114" valign="top">promote channel width="78">22 width="84">22.0 width="99">22.0 width="119">22.0 | > give entertainment width="78">22 width="84">22.0 width="99">22.0 width="119">44.0 | > gain profit width="78">56 width="84">56.0 width="99">56.0 width="119">100.0 | > Total width="78">100 width="84">100.0 width="99">100.0 width="119">
| |
22% think that Pakistani media channels are buying foreign dramas in order to promote the channel. 22% think that giving entertainment is the reason for buying foreign dramas, while most of the 56% of people believe that Pakistani media channels are buying foreign dramas in order to gain profit.
Table 7. Turkish Dramas Should Ban in our TV Channels
| width="96"> Frequency width="85">Percent width="115">Valid Percent width="121">Cumulative Percent | > Valid width="61" valign="top">yes width="96">42 width="85">42.0 width="115">42.0 width="121">42.0 | > no width="96">58 width="85">58.0 width="115">58.0 width="121">100.0 | > Total width="96">100 width="85">100.0 width="115">100.0 width="121">
| |